I wanted to follow up on some of the discussion here, especially since it touches on a few things I mentioned back in July in my post about making the game experience deeper.
I still really enjoy DC: TG and appreciate everything that's gone into it, but I agree with some of the frustrations being raised.
- First, the Financial Management
I understand the goal of making the financial side gritty and realistic. Running a corps is expensive (look at the Cadets), and I think that challenge should remain part of the game. However, I feel the attention finances requires takes away from the more enjoyable aspects of the game or makes it harder for anyone other then the top groups to keep through a season. It also makes it harder for people who would participate more in a normie style. Maybe we could approach finances through sponsorships, donations, or occasional events that require us to make decisions. I wouldn't necessarily want finances to become too easy, just less repetitive and less central to the overall experience.
- Second, the Daily Rehearsals and Scenarios
One thing I would love to see is some sort of daily or occasional scenario system. Rather than simply logging in to complete rehearsal, maybe we could have situations involving our members, staff, or the organization itself. Marching band drama is a thing, and we all know there is always some sort of drama or issue going on behind the scenes.
For example: your Brass and Visual Caption Heads might disagree over rehearsal time, a member might be struggling with morale (someone with low loyalty), or your staff might want to increase the show's difficulty at the risk of hurting execution. You could choose how to respond, with small effects on the corps.
I think something like that could make the game feel more like we're actually directing a corps. The normal rehearsal system could still be there for those who prefer it, or perhaps these scenarios could occasionally appear alongside it.
- Third, the Show Design and Corps Identity
This also ties into what I suggested back in July about giving directors more choices in show design. I'd still love to see a system where we could choose a design philosophy, whether that is visual, musical, percussion, guard, or balanced, and make decisions about things like drill complexity, staging, and demand. Each could have its own advantages and trade-offs without requiring AI to judge artistic merit. I know several of us enjoy creating actual productions, artwork, and even Micro Marching League drill for our corps. It would be nice to see more opportunities to include that creativity in the experience, perhaps through community events or showcases.
Here is the link:
https://drumcorpsthegame.com/forums/topic/136
Overall though, I think the game has a strong foundation, and I certainly don't want to lose the management and competitive aspects that make it interesting. I would love to see more opportunities for meaningful decisions and a little more variety in what we do each day.